Connecticut Audio Society 2011 Speaker Shootout
Every year, the CT Audio Society <
http://ctuadio.org> has a meeting that is a speaker shootout, where we compare speakers back to back (without breaking your back when you try to carry them). This event usually takes place during the summer and it did so again this year. But I neglected to post my notes from the listening session, so here they are now.
These are very general comments that I was typing into my phone as we went along. I would normally go into more detail about what I heard, but there’s not a lot of time for that at this particular event. Throughout my comments, I refer very generically to music tracks used for the listening session. So here’s an explanation of what I’m referring to (1) "drums/bells/cymbals" is an excerpt from Mickey Hart’s Planet Drum, (2) “piano” is from Keith Jarrett’s Melody at Night, (3) “Ricky Nelson” is the song Never Be Anyone Else But You (not sure why this track was chosen, as I thought it was not suitable for speaker comparison purposes — I had no say in these selections), (4) “guitar” duo from Paul McCartney Unplugged, (5) Tracy Chapman’s Fast Car.
First up were Mike B.'s 70's ADC bookshelf speakers: good dynamics on drums, piano shows peaky frequencies, ricky nelson no bottom end whatsoever, guitar very nice, tracy chapman ok. overall a fine speaker that was probably a stand out for its era.
Minimus 17: did not like. harsh and bright on bells/cymbals, piano sounds small, gtr unimpressive, chapman very forward.
Walt's big Advents: pleasant mid bass, but limited dynamics, piano track gave no ambient sense of the recording space. not very revealing of detail and not my cup of tea.
JSE Infinite Slope: Closed in sounding at the top end, seems to roll of quickly in the highs, but otherwise very musical, dynamics good, piano track very pleasant, had bass on nelson track when others didn't, guitar track missing detail on the top end.
The DIY speakers of Mike from Rhode Island: Overall a very good speaker, and among the upper percentile of the speakers heard. Bells very nice, not as much bass as I'd like, dynamics a bit restricted, piano good but not remarkable, gtr very good but not enough body/fullness, nice air on chapman's pop song.
Martin Logan Motion 2: Tiny little things that did quite well in such a big room. Bells were very detailed -- in fact among the best of the day, no bass at all however, and they sounded strained at times, a little bit of ringing on the piano, gtr detail rendered well but significantly lacking body, chapman sounded good.
Advent 3 small speaker: Didn't like. Big bass hump around 150 hertz, piano boomy, seems to be tuned to impress in showroom, not for long-term happiness, however chapman sounded ok.
Titus Stella ES: percussion too bright, piano too sharp, but provided a strong sound of the guitar strings for a pleasing effect, no bass on chapman.
B&W 601: Bells OK but slightly smeared and leaning towards harsh on drum track, no really deep bass, but definitely a bass hump above 100hz, not good on piano at all -- lots of ringing, bass bump was somewhat pleasing on chapman but leaned towards excess, her vocal sounded lousy. Not impressed with this B&W model.
Boehlender Z1: Bells among the very best of the day, bass good, but mids too strong, piano sounded nasal, nice air on chapman's vocal but was ruined by nasality.
Dunlavey SC-I: Bells nice, but no bottom end and some peakiness around 500 hz, piano ok, among the best on ricky nelson, good on guitar but not among the best, very good on chapman but not remarkable, needs more bass. The clarity was among the top ten for the day. But overall the lack of bass really hurt their ability to give a full musical image.
Dynaco horizontal speaker (model 20XL?): These are bad. Bells sharp, though there is some decent imaging, the presence region is way too hot -- almost painful, piano rings and has no body, harsh on nelson vocal, guitar is nasal with no body and snare too prominent, chapman sounded awful. Could not wait for these speakers to be turned off.
EAW professional sub/sat system (SB48/UB12) that Larry D. brought: These were simply fabulous from top to bottom. Bells were really really good, bass is wonderful, for the first time I heard the presence of guitar on this track -- something I hadn't noticed before, piano very realistic with nice air, for the first time during this day of listening, I actually enjoyed the ricky nelson track and was able to notice details in the backing vocals that were otherwise unnoticed, guitar track was very involving and musical, excellent detail to the bass, these were among the very best for tracy chapman and had great bass extension, her guitar had detail missing on other speakers, larry turned the sub on its side and had us listen to chapman again. result: bass response was smoother. Overall, these were my pick for the very best of the day.